about reputation


In a comment about a recent study whose neutrality was not so clear I was asked by a reader:

If there is all this data as you say on the internet then why do you need this reputation thing at all, i mean can’t you just check wether this Greiser person is right?

The study which the reader meant to be checked used data about leukemia occurences in children who lived in the vicinity of a nuclear power plant. This data was -to a great extend- gathered together via the internet and was then statistically evaluated. So the reader assumed that -given that all the necessary information is available- that one could just check wether the study is right.

My answer:
In principle -given that all information is provided in the study- and – given that oneself can access all data (this is unfortunately not always that easy) one can check wether all the in the study given data was correctly evaluated, one can follow the statistic reasoning and the methods which were used a.s.o. The question wether the study is correct or not should thus not be expected to be answered plainly with a yes or no, but at least include explanations about the involved methodology. All that takes a lot of knowledge and experience which is -for an outsider- not so easy to acquire. That is even though I am a mathematician it would take me probably quite some time to understand and evaluate the involved reasoning (it is not exactly my field), it is quite likely that I would end up with open questions and thus would need to consult other people.

One can compare this a little bit with a medical diagnosis, that is in principle all the medical information is available in text books, articles etc. and without having studied medicine one can have a “feeling” about how correct a diagnosis is, however – depending on the symptoms and ones own knowledge- people usually prefer to see a doctor instead of feeling inclined to cure themselves. The craftmanship of a mathematician -although this may not be so obvious- is comparable to that of a physician.

Nevertheless it happens that people won’t go see a doctor. This may happen because people can’t afford to pay a doctor and/or because they are convinced that their methods (or those of a non-medical-doctor) are better. And there are indeed cases were non-doctors may have better results. Nevertheless the typical scenario is that a learned doctor knows more and can help you better than a non-doctor. This holds also true for “crowd knowledge” that is you may ask around in fora about what to do with what symptoms, but typically you wouldnt like to rely on them completely.

Here one should note an important feature: Among others a doctor is someone who was evaluated by a certain group of people who know the subject. That is professional organisations, universities etc. hand out certificates which should give you some trust that this person knows what he/she is saying and doing. This is mostly what reputation is about. It is a guideline. Or put differently: Given a specified task the chance that you will end up with a completely incapable person which had been certified for this task by a respectable institution should be smaller than the chance that an uncertified person is incapable. This doesnt exclude the case that there are uncertified persons with a better knowledge than certified ones. This is just -at the moment- on average less likely.

I wrote “at the moment”, because there are unfortunately tendencies which dilute this rather helpful feature, as can be seen e.g. in the certification problem in the already mentioned outsourced learning environments/online classes. Certification problems can also be found in “cheap education” e.g. by certifying large amounts of students, which makes cheating easier (for example by handing in essays, which were not authored by oneself), academic misconduct and/or corruption e.g. due to financial interests etc. Moreover the possibilities for free autonomous learning are much, much better than before (which is good), so the number of highly trained individuals without a certificate are most probably on the rise. Traditional systems of evaluation may thus be loosing their influence. Personal recomendations would thus become more important, which makes it on the other hand harder to enter a foreign field as an outsider.

The above (unemployed) patient in the foto had a bad bike accident, which resulted unfortunately not only in a torn muscle. Thanks to a “still” rather good medical care in Germany within one week and with the help of several specialists and MRI a not so common injury could be diagnostized fastly and within 2 months the patient should be able to walk properly again….

Why do I write “still”?

Because in Germany the costs for health care are on the rise. This is not only due to an aging population but also to a great extend due to rising costs for pharmaceutical products, where new, patented products play a major role. According to this article in Berliner Zeitung on total the costs for physicians in Germany are meanwhile smaller than the costs for pharmaceutical products. Nevertheless suggestions of politicians which are about to form Germanys new government suggest to cut down on health care on the whole and instead secure a socalled “basic care” for the masses which could be supplemented by additional care – if you have the money. As a result the stockmarket for certain pharmaceutical companies soared right after the elections.

historical reading: -> hippocratic oath

7 Responses to “about reputation”

  1. Victor Says:

    Your patient should be happy that her health insurance pays this posh knee-burka. In our times a broken leg was fixed with simple plaster!

  2. nad Says:

    Victor Says:

    >Your patient should be happy that her health insurance pays this posh knee-burka. In our >times a broken leg was fixed with simple plaster!

    unfortunately this was a cruciate ligament rupture. This means that the leg has to be stabilized for 8 weeks with braces like the above. if you would put the leg in plaster then
    you have no possibility anymore for training, moreover if the plaster is done badly you may
    actually loose your leg alltogether.

  3. nad Says:

    “kraft weg” photography by Harry Gähni

    this is how the decline in muscles looks after about 3-4 weeks, even with a little training.

  4. Harry Gähnie Says:

    I posted this comment already some days ago, but it seems it got somehow lost.
    Thanks for posting this photography, it is actually a collaboration with my colleague Ballwenig who is in charge for the scene set up. We haven’t yet set up a homepage for ourselves, but at least it is good that our names are getting circulated.
    By the way did your knee-burka patient recover? It can be dangerous to postpone medical treatment.

  5. nad Says:

    @Harry Gähnie and Kollege Ballwenig:

    Well, I don’t know what happened to the comment, thanks for your above re-comment.
    Knock on wood the “knee-burka” patient has basically no knee-problems anymore. The recovering was actually so good that she went dancing again. But probably a little bit too carefreely she took part in a dancing class with twentysomethings. Probably a lack of body control and training lead unfortunately recently to a hand injury.
    With the hand injury she actually didn’t first want to see a doctor but then – when seeing guitars in a newspaper- she was reminded that maltreatment could actually have big consequences for her ability to play the guitar (she is in her fifties and has just started to learn the guitar so luckily that wouldnt have too my carreer implications :) – but still)

    In fact the nature of the injury really seemed not very clear: when she arrived in the emergency room the nurse there said: “I wouldn’t have come in here with such an injury, this heals by itself” patient: “If you say this is just a minor injury then I would go home” (there was over an hour waiting time (which is not much)) nurse: “What do you want – a voucher?! – since you have already checked in you should see the doctor!” the doctor finally when looking at the hand said: “This happened the day before yesterday- why do you come in only now?!” (Krankenshwester: also wissnse ick würd mit sowat nich uffkreuzn, dit biecht sich doch von alleene grade, patient: “Wenn Sie mir bestätigen, dass das nichts schlimmes ist, dann würde ich wieder nach Hause gehen”, Krankenshwester: watt wollse ne quittung?! jetz hamse mia ia kärtchen jejebn un jetz jehn se mal schön rin zum doktor.” Doctor: Das ist vorgestern passiert und warum kommen Sie damit erst jetzt?! )

    An X-ray showed that one finger was actually partially broken and has to stay in braces for 2 weeks.

    How to cool a finger

  6. Victor Says:

    nad wrote:

    “An X-ray showed that one finger was actually partially broken and has to stay in braces for 2 weeks.”

    I bet your excessive german health system is providing patient now with expensive physical therapy paid with higher european state debts!

    why would fifty-something need learn guitar and dance? Have you thought about how annoying bad music? Want to be in the cellulightslimelite? Rockstargrannies are worst. Time to grow up!

  7. nad Says:

    Victor wrote:

    I bet your excessive german health system is providing patient now with expensive physical therapy paid with higher european state debts!

    Actually (after almost 2hrs waiting) the doctor said that he had no budget anymore for a physical therapy, and that the finger should get OK by itself. A little doubtful the patient then called a doctor at the health assurance who said that if one doesn’t train the finger properly then it might stay stiff forever and that the patient should better see an orthopaedic surgeon and then let send the patient a list of adresses with physical therapists. The physical therapists then said that the only possibility to get advice on how to train the finger would be to go to the doctor and to ask for filling out a new kind of form (I forgot how it was called “green form” may be) and then pay privately for a therapy. So the patient is now hoping that the doctor was right that it would heal by itself.

Leave a Reply

The below box is for leaving comments. Interesting comments in german, french and russian will eventually be translated into english. If you write a comment you consent to our data protection practices as specified here. If your comment text is not too rude and if your URL is not clearly SPAM then both will be published after moderation. Your email adress will not be published. Moderation is done by hand and might take up to a couple of days.
you can use LaTeX in your math comments, by using the [latex] shortcode:
[latex] E = m c^2 [/latex]